Dear Search Engine Roundtable,

Since I subscribed to your feed (in early 2005), I have received and read every post you’ve made using my RSS reader of choice (Google Reader, currently). Your excerpts have been enticing, with well-written post titles and seemingly interesting topics. The idea was good, to aggregate content and discussions about Search Engines from multiple locations at one central blog.

Unfortunately, I’ve found that your articles are less informative than I’d have hoped, with frequent referrals to other locations where the conversations are actually taking place. Instead of effective bullet points and topic reviews, I find quick and hastily-written overviews of the content and discussion in question.

Not only that, but you’re only providing partial content in your feeds! When I come across your posts in my daily reading of over 500 posts, you’ve caught my attention with your title - and because you’re only giving me the partial article text, you’ve got me clicking through to your site (hoorah, ad impressions!). Unfortunately, half the time I’m wasting even more time by being forced to click through to yet another page to follow the conversation.

I rarely (if ever) find myself sharing your content, and from what I can tell from a cursory glance - you’ve never shown up in my shared items feed. (PS, when will I be able to control this page, Google? I hope this link juice means something in the future. Maybe even market that page in a bit more of a controlled fashion. I digress.) I’ve maybe starred one or two of your articles for future reading, but again - when I do finally read the posts, I find that I’m disappointed by your article quality and content.

What’s up with that?! Alright, rabid feedreaders and social media evangelists - tell me if I’m in the wrong here, but I’m going to unsubscribe from Search Engine Roundtable.

So, entirely not in light of any recent events, I was integrating the chat rules that Vexar wrote into RolePlayGateway’s Rules, and I was looking for some examples of forum etiquette that other forums use. In searching, I found this perfectly humorous video:

(I found it on Neil Boortz’s website, but since headed over to videojug to get the original. PS, Neil? You’re awesome.)

That was probably the best one I found, above and beyond the video I came across that seemed geared towards the Steam forum community, which was a bit too NSFW to actually embed here on my blog. If you’d like, you can go check out posting a new thread on AlbinoBlackSheep.

I’m admin on several online forums, and I’m a moderator on many more; not counting the countless other communities where I’m an active member. I was pretty proud of the rules I put together on Gateway, and I think they’re clean, simple, and easy to follow. No one likes being bombarded and tacked down by rules, so I try to keep them as simple as possible. What do you think of them?

How do you manage forum users and set rules? I know Martin Reed has some good tips on forum rules, and there are many others out there that learned a lot from running forums. The best thing that we can do is learn from others, and gather experience on how to handle these issues. What is your approach to forum etiquette?